DiscoverCars.Com

Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric top variant: Which offers more value?

Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric top variant: Which offers more value?
Maruti finally launched the e Vitara, its first electric offering, more than a year after unveiling it. Priced competitively from Rs 15.99 lakh ex-showroom, inclusive of battery, the e Vitara sits in the heavily contested midsize EV space, with the Creta Electric – the EV counterpart of Hyundai’s bestseller – being a close rival. In this article, we compare their top-spec variants, the e Vitara Alpha and the Creta Electric Excellence LR, to see which one offers more value.  

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Dimensions

e Vitara has a longer wheelbase, but Creta Electric offers additional frunk storage

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara top spec vs Hyundai Creta Electric top spec: Dimensions

 

Maruti e Vitara

Hyundai Creta Electric

Difference

Length (mm)

4,275

4,340

-65

Width (mm)

1,800

1,790

+10

Height (mm)

1,640

1,655

-15

Wheelbase (mm)

2,700

2,610

+90

Ground clearance (mm)

185

200

-15

Boot space (litres)

306

433

-127

Frunk space (litres)

NA

22

-22

The e Vitara has a 90mm longer wheelbase than the Creta Electric and is slightly wider. However, the Hyundai is 65mm longer, rides 15mm higher and has 127 litres more boot space, not to mention an additional frunk that the e Vitara lacks.

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Battery and range

e Vitara boasts a bigger battery pack and a higher claimed range  

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Battery and range

 

Maruti e Vitara

Hyundai Creta Electric

Battery size (kWh)

61

51.4

Motor setup

Single motor, front

Single motor, front

Power (hp)

174

171

Torque (Nm)

193

255

ARAI range (km)

543

510

In the top-spec version, the Creta Electric comes with a 51.4kWh battery pack and the e Vitara with a 61kWh unit. Both have a front-axle-mounted single-motor setup. While the e Vitara slightly nudges ahead with 3hp more, the Creta Electric packs more grunt with 62Nm higher torque output. As for claimed range, the e Vitara can go up to 33km further than the Creta Electric on a single charge.

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Charging speed and time

Creta Electric supports faster charging speeds

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Charging speed and time

 

Maruti e Vitara

Hyundai Creta Electric

AC charging speed support (kW)

Up to 7.4kW

Up to 11kW

DC charging speed support (kW)

Up to 70kW

Up to 100kW

10-100 percent AC charging time (hours)

4.5

10-80 percent DC charging time (minutes)

45

39

The Creta Electric supports faster charging speeds: home top-up is up to 11kW AC versus 7.4kW maximum for the e Vitara, while the DC fast charging goes as high as 100kW compared to the rival’s 70kW. Thus, juicing up the Creta Electric is quicker not only because of faster charging support but also due to a smaller battery. 

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Exterior features

e Vitara runs on larger wheels and gets fog lamps

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Exterior features

 

Maruti e Vitara

Hyundai Creta Electric 

Headlights

LED

Connected LED

Tail-lights

Connected LED

Connected LED

DRLs

Yes

Yes

Front fog lamps

Yes

No

Wheels

18-inch

17-inch

Door handles

Body coloured

Body coloured

Rear spoiler

Yes

Yes

Power-adjustable ORVMs 

Yes

Yes

Shark-fin antenna

Yes

Yes

Colours

Monotone and Dual-tone

Monotone and Dual-tone

Both the e Vitara and the Creta Electric come with LED light setups, but the e Vitara additionally gets fog lamps. Moreover, its alloy wheels are a size larger at 18 inches. Monotone and dual-tone colour options are offered with both models, but only the Creta Electric can be opted for with a matte finish for the exterior. Notably, the e Vitara is purely a born-electric model, while the Creta Electric is an ICE-to-EV converted model.

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Interior features

Creta Electric packs more feel-good features

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Interior features

 

Maruti e Vitara 

Hyundai Creta Electric

Infotainment screen

10.1-inch

10.25-inch

Driver’s display

10.25-inch

10.25-inch

Front seat ventilation

Yes

Yes

Powered driver’s seat

10-way

8-way

Powered front passenger seat

No

Yes

Android Auto, Apple CarPlay

Yes

Yes

Audio system

10-speaker Infinity audio

8-speaker Bose audio

Sunroof

Single pane, fixed glass

Panoramic

Boss mode (front passenger seat)

No

Electrically adjustable

Rear-seat recline

Yes

Yes

Climate control

Single zone

Dual-zone

Seat upholstery

Leatherette

Leatherette

Wireless phone charger

Yes

Yes (both rows)

Rear sunshades

No

Yes

Ambient lighting

Yes

Yes

Front centre armrest

Yes

Yes

Rear centre armrest

Yes

Yes

Cooled glove box

No

Yes

USB ports

2x Type-A, 2x Type-C

3x Type-C

Connected car tech

Yes

Yes

The e Vitara comes with leatherette dashboard inserts, additional adjustment for the powered driver’s seat, two extra speakers and more USB ports over its rival. But the Creta Electric offers more useful features, such as a powered front passenger seat with boss mode, a panoramic sunroof, dual-zone AC, a wireless phone charger for the second row and a cooled glove box.

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Driving tech

Drive modes are same, but e Vitara also gets a snow mode

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Driving tech

 

Maruti e Vitara

Hyundai Creta Electric

Drive modes

Eco, Normal and Sport

Eco, Normal and Sport

Terrain modes

Snow

-

Cruise control

Adaptive

Adaptive

Both EVs come with three drive modes, but only the e Vitara offers a dedicated terrain mode: snow.  

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Safety Features

While e Vitara offers an additional airbag, Creta Electric has an in-built dashcam 

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Safety kit

 

Maruti e Vitara

Hyundai Creta Electric

Airbags

7

6

ADAS

Level 2

Level 2

Camera setup

360-degree

360-degree

Parking sensors

Front and rear

Front and rear

Electric parking brake

Yes

Yes

Disc Brakes

All wheels

All wheels

TPMS

Yes

Yes

IRVM

Auto-dimming

Auto-dimming

Hill hold control

Yes

Yes

Hill descent control

No

Yes

ESC

Yes

Yes

Dashcam

No

Yes

Both are packed with safety features and appear more or less matched in this area, but the e Vitara gets an additional airbag, and the Creta Electric offers an in-built dashcam. While the Creta Electric has not been tested for safety, the e Vitara has achieved a 5-star rating from BNCAP.

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Prices and verdict

Top-spec Maruti e Vitara vs Hyundai Creta Electric: Prices

 

Maruti e Vitara Alpha

Hyundai Creta Electric Excellence LR

Price (Rs lakh)

19.79

23.66

We would pick the e Vitara, as it not only offers a bigger battery pack with a higher claimed range but is also Rs 3.87 lakh more affordable. While the Creta Electric supports much faster charging speeds, packs some additional feel-good and convenience features, such as a cooled glove box, rear sunshades, a panoramic sunroof and boss mode, along with more storage space, it does not justify the price premium over the e Vitara.



from Autocar India https://ift.tt/MANIr3u

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hyundai Exter variant wise powertrain details revealed

390 Duke or Interceptor 650: Best bike for casual riding under Rs 4 lakh?

New MG 4 EV revealed as Creta sized hatchback